Broadcasting at 89.5 FM from the wilderlands of New Jersey, Seton
Hall University's WSOU,
the aptly-named "Pirate Radio," has been bringing diversity
of choice and new music to the New York metropolitan area for over
fifteen years. Backed by the University, the WSOU staff, composed
of Seton Hall students, has been free to broadcast a program mainly
consisting of mainstream and underground heavy metal bands, mixed
in with the odd hip-hop program, Celtic music, sports broadcasts,
and church and community services. However, the mainstay of WSOU programming
are the metal programs, in which the DJs, not the indies, have control
over what they play and when.
In response
to an e-mailed query, Thomas Katchisin, the current WSOU program
director, wrote: "I was the music director last year and I
can tell you that the most pressure I felt from anyone was a label
telling me that the band was a big priority for them. . . All I
was looking for was a good, quality, recording, and something that
for the most part didn't sound like everything else."
However,
though WSOU would seem to be largely immune to outside pressure,
there are other issues involved. Katchisin continued: "The
University is a sensitive issue, especially since WSOU is part of
a Catholic university. We have to make sure that our screening process
for music is tight, so that we do not play any music over the airwaves
that doesn't fit with Seton Hall University's and WSOU's mission
statements."
A station
DJ who broadcasts under the handle "The Captain" expanded
on Katchisin's comments: "For example, the band Cradle
of Filth was pulled because of the content of their songs.
'Opiate'
by Tool was redlined because it talks about Jesus Christ raping
people. We cannot say the name of the Nirvana LP 'Incesticide.'
We're not allowed so say anything negative about the University
or the Church. We cannot make racial, sexual, or ethnic comments.
So, the university is a far bigger censor than the FCC is."
Of course,
many would argue that such interference is reasonable. Running a
radio station takes money, and if the funding is coming from a private
source, such as the Catholic Church, then the private source does
have a right to ask that the broadcast not contain material it finds
objectionable. Such a policy may even work to the station's advantages,
allowing a wider age range of listeners, as well as working to attract
those driven away by the vulgar antics of big-station DJs. Finally,
such an ideologically-based policy, so long as alternative outlets
for non-censored speech exist, is far less onerous than censorship
based solely on commercial reasons. CORPORATE MOFO may not agree
with the Catholic Church on very many issues, but we will still
defend their right to make their opinions known, through either
speech or silence, on their own radio station. And, it should also
be noted, even with this interference, WSOU is still given huge
leeway with regards to content.
And what
content it is. There's a certain charm to hearing a bunch of college
kids play songs by bands that they're really into. You can tell
these kids get a real thrill playing "met-ahl" over the
airwaves. Tuning in to WSOU is a more real, authentic experience
than listening to slick radio "personalities" shoot their
mouths off. In an era of narrowly-defined market segments, WSOU
easily plays the greatest variety of bands in its listening area,
and gives a number of new artists an opportunity to be heard.
Daniel
"The Raven" Spezzacatena, a DJ and assistant music director,
gave voice to the concerns of many on one issue. "I personally
think that we, WSOU, are the originators of many bands. We play
the bands that commercial radio stations do not play and make them
popular. A few years ago, half the bands on [a certain commercial
radio station that shall remain nameless] started with us."
"Still,
it is nice to see that the fans do not forget. At a great deal of
shows, SOU chants break out. . . Many fans were wearing homemade
"[a certain commercial radio station that shall remain nameless]
Sucks/WSOU Rules" T-shirts. And that is what it is all about,
the fans. As long as the fans know what the truth is, then that's
fine. Rock and roll will live on forever, and it's nice to know
that WSOU is a great part of it."
One could
easily argue that it's only natural that a certain number of the
bands that WSOU originates make it big, and are accordingly pushed
onto corporate radio by big record labels, but Spezzacatena's comment
is borne out by my own experience. Many moons ago, one of the first
Limp Bizkit shows in New York was sponsored by a certain commercial
radio station that shall remain nameless. My friend Luigi dragged
me along to see this "great new band he heard on WSOU"
(he had gotten great joy out of dedicating "Counterfeit"
to his ex-girlfriend). When Fred Durst came out to thank that certain
radio station that shall remain nameless, he was shouted down as
almost literally the entire auditorium began a ten-minute-long chant
of "S-O-U! S-O-U!"
Yet,
the WSOU DJs seemed reluctant to think of themselves as musical
mujahedeen. Katchisin also wrote: ". . . in regards to us thinking
of ourselves as revolutionaries, I can't speak for everyone else,
but for myself, I am just another DJ working for a really cool station.
The station overall however, I do think is revolutionary. Going
back 15 years ago when we first starting playing metal, all the
way up to the present, WSOU is one of a kind. The station plays
music that most commercial radio stations will never touch, or will
play but only in a specialty show rotation."
The Captain,
while also protesting his own lack of revolutionary fervor, nailed
the issue right on the head: "Some people at the station. .
. place high priority on spinning bands that normally wouldn't get
played anywhere else, even during WSOU's regular rotation. . . I
don't see myself as a visionary. I love WSOU to death and will do
anything I can to support up and coming bands (such as D-9
and Dizneyfist)
but I'm not totally in love with all of the music we play. However,
even though I may not like it, I will fight for my fellow DJs' right
to play that music and the right for our audience to hear it. .
. . What bothers me most about [traditional, commercial music outlets]
is the fact that it such a sanitized, focus-group derived form of
entertainment. I could put a mooing cow on MTV and in three weeks
the "Moo Cow America" LP will be at #1. Too many people
in this country are drones of the constantly-consolidating industry.
WSOU represents free will more than it represents heavy metal, and
I think that's why it's so popular. WSOU is the anti-status quo."
The question
remains, however: what can we, the consumers, do about the status
quo, besides chanting at rock shows? The first is to write or e-mail
your Congresspeople to have the Telecommunications act
of 1996 repealed. The second is: Boycott commercial radio, or at
least lie to Arbitron about what stations you listen to.
Down
with commercial radio, up with goofy college kids!
About
the Authors: Tristan Trout and Ken Mondschein, though crappy
musicians, are avid music fans. More to the point, they're rabid
about freedom of expression.